Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register free for our breaking news email alerts with analysis and cutting edge commentary from our award winning team. Registration only takes a minute.

Whistleblower wins unfair dismissal case against wealth boutique

2 Comments
Whistleblower wins unfair dismissal case against wealth boutique

A portfolio manager was unfairly dismissed by wealth firm Creechurch Capital, which allegedly falsified records in its dealings with two clients, an employment tribunal has found.

Robert Sutton, who worked at the Isle of Man-based firm from 2013 until February 2016, took Creechurch to court saying his dismissal was ‘a retaliatory act’ aimed at disparaging his character.

The Isle of Man employment tribunal ruled in favour of Sutton in May 2017 saying he was ‘automatically unfairly dismissed because of protected disclosures he had made’ and added that compensation would be determined at a later date. This ruling was published this month.

Creechurch, led by former Wealth Manager cover star John Greenwood, stated that it dismissed Sutton for using instant messaging app WhatsApp to communicate with clients – which the firm considered gross misconduct.

However, the tribunal found that the reason for his dismissal was because he discussed concerns about the company with the regulator, the Isle of Man Financial Services Authority (FSA), earlier regarding two protected disclosures.

The first was a suspicious transaction report made to the firm’s compliance officer on 29 May 2015 detailing his concern that Creechurch was falsifying records in relation to two clients. The second was the fact he had spoken to and assisted the FSA on 10 December 2015 during a three-day routine inspection. A subsequent FSA report stated that it was concerned that its findings ‘may be indicative of a lack of fitness and propriety at Creechurch’.

Sutton alleged that Creechurch had attempted to make him a ‘scapegoat’ and tried to paint him as a ‘lone rogue’. He contended this was to deflect attention from other failures at the firm.

Greenwood told Wealth Manager: ‘We’re deeply disappointed with the decision of the tribunal. We engaged an external HR consultant to advise on the dismissal and have followed the advice of highly-regarded legal professionals throughout the tribunal process and despite the final decision, we still believe our original grounds and decision to dismiss were justified.

‘Although the matter in question was two years ago, we endeavour to learn and improve our business from every experience. We’ve continued to invest heavily in our talented and professional team, infrastructure and compliance to ensure we hold ourselves accountable to the highest standards for our clients.’

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
2 Comments Play Liam Halligan: the eurozone is about to implode

Liam Halligan: the eurozone is about to implode

The economist and broadcaster told the Citywire Private Office Retreat he believes a potential implosion of the eurozone is the biggest threat markets face today.

1 Comment Play James Anderson: my great fear and hope for the next 10 years

James Anderson: my great fear and hope for the next 10 years

Co-manager of Scottish Mortgage Trust says the financial world has not changed since the banking crisis but predicts the next decade will bring unprecedented upheaval in all areas of the market.

1 Comment Play What wealth managers told clients the day Lehmans went bust

What wealth managers told clients the day Lehmans went bust

We asked wealth managers to go back in time at Citywire North as the 10-year anniversary of the Lehmans collapse approached.

Read More
Your Business: Cover Star Club

Profile: UBS' new UK boss on her plans to win wealth

Profile: UBS' new UK boss on her plans to win wealth

UBS’s wealth arm might be the fourth biggest in the UK, but it still has only 4% of the market share, says incoming boss Eva Lindholm

Wealth Manager on Twitter