Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register free for our breaking news email alerts with analysis and cutting edge commentary from our award winning team. Registration only takes a minute.

What fund selectors can learn from World War II

What fund selectors can learn from World War II

Of all the heroes of World War II, Abraham Wald is probably one of the least known.

His anonymity should not be surprising, though. As a statistician, his role lacks the necessary glamour to be made into a movie.

Nonetheless, his story deserves to be more widely known.

During WWII, there was a process of analysing planes returning from combat, making careful study of the heavily damaged parts and then reinforcing them.

These planes showed a consistent pattern of damage, with the wings and the tail sections taking far greater damage than the fuselage. Reinforce those, went the assumption, and the planes would better survive hits.

Though logical, this insight was – as Abraham realised – completely wrong. The planes being examined were the ones to have made it back safely.

But these were exactly the wrong planes to look at, as the only information they yielded was where a plane could take a hit and still make it back.

It was, instead, the planes that did not return that needed to be studied. These planes showed a completely different pattern, with damage around the fuselage, the engine and the cockpit.

Such a mistake of correctly interpreting (‘reinforce damaged parts’) from the wrong sample (‘planes that made it’), is known in behavioural economics as survivorship bias.

While this bias is known, investors keep making it for the same reason the military almost did in WWII. Some information is easier to gain than other information, leading to the risk of making the right decision based on the wrong information.

For instance, in looking for an active Japanese equity fund, many might assess the available funds according to typical success metrics – such as excess return – of the last few years.

However, this could lead to the survivorship bias trap. Why? In the past, Japan has had a monetary policy deliberately weakening the yen, a process boosting export companies at the expense of domestics.

Looking at the sample of active funds during this period, some top-performing active funds were focused on the exporters at the expense of domestic companies.

However, this sample of top-performing Japanese equity managers is probably the wrong sample from which to select. Japan now has a policy focused on domestic corporate reform, not on weakening the yen.

As a result, selectors should seek out active funds focused on the impacts of the domestic reform, rather than on exporters – just as the military paradoxically needed to focus on the parts not damaged on the planes, not the parts that were.

So, when selecting a fund, Japanese equity or otherwise, it is wise to remember the story of Abraham Wald and the damaged planes of WWII.

It is important to spend as much time understanding the specific sample, as selecting the funds from this sample.

In short, do not make the right deductions using the wrong sample: more reinforced wings would have done nothing to help those pilots that crashed across Europe and never returned.

Nick Samouilhan (pictured) is solutions strategist, EMEA, for T Rowe Price


Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
Citywire TV
2 Comments Play Tim Steer: how to spot a stock disaster coming

Tim Steer: how to spot a stock disaster coming

The former Citywire AAA-rated fund manager has written a book on 22 stock disasters and how forensic examination of annual reports could have spotted them coming.

Play CEO tapes: the gap between best and worst alternatives is stark

CEO tapes: the gap between best and worst alternatives is stark

In the final part of our series we take a look at the rise of illiquid investing and whether it really serves in clients best interests.

Play CEO Tapes: dangerous data and great technology

CEO Tapes: dangerous data and great technology

In the third part of our latest series the debate turns to technology and the huge impact it is having on the fund management industry.

Read More
Wealth Manager on Twitter