Wealth Manager - the site for professional investment managers

Register to get unlimited access to Citywire’s fund manager database. Registration is free and only takes a minute.

All Skewed Up? The Active Versus Passive Debate

All Skewed Up? The Active Versus Passive Debate

By James Moore, Head of Investment Solutions, PIMCO

There has been a lot of discussion about a recent academic paper, "Why Indexing Works," which makes a statistical case for passive investing in equities. The same logic applied to bonds, though, may make the opposite case: Passive fixed income management doesn't work, but active bond management does.

The core of the argument for passive equity investing is the skewness of returns and hence further skewness in outcomes that arise when one looks at the resultant stock prices. While a normal distribution of returns is a reasonable approximation of outcomes and generates prices that are log-normally distributed and positively skewed, it understates what we observe in practice.

To give a motivating example, the most an investor can lose from an equity investment is all of that investment – 100%. But if we look at the S&P 500 for 2016, the top-performing stock, Nvidia, was up 227% for the year. There's much greater upside than downside – positive skewness.

Bonds are different

If individual stock returns are positively skewed, what can we say about bond returns? We could go through the laborious exercise of examining return data, but a more elegant approach would be to appeal to the seminal work of Nobel laureate Robert Merton. The value of a company is the sum of the market values of its debt and its equity. As such, the equity is a perpetual call option on the value of a firm’s assets in excess of the face value of the debt. Further, corporate debt is the sum of risk-free debt plus a sold put with a strike price equal to the face value of debt. Calls are positively skewed; puts are negatively skewed.

Presented another way, what is the most an investor could get back on a bond? If the bond is held to maturity, the investor gets accrued interest, future coupons and the principal. While bonds can appreciate in market value, over the life of the bond under most circumstances it returns approximately the yield. If the issuer defaults on the bond, the return can be substantially less. A likely return with capped upside – plus a possible return of substantial loss – equals a negatively skewed distribution of returns.

If positive skewness is a headwind to active management, does negative skewness provide a tailwind? I’ll leave it to the academics to do the laborious work to disprove the conjecture – if they can.

In the meantime, it's another indication that bonds are different than stocks.

For more on active management, please see "Why Bonds Are Different."

All investments contain risk and may lose value. This material is intended for informational purposes only. Forecasts, estimates and certain information contained herein are based upon proprietary research and should not be considered as investment advice or a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. No part of this material may be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without express written permission. PIMCO is a trademark of Allianz Asset Management of America L.P. in the United States and throughout the world. THE NEW NEUTRAL is a trademark of Pacific Investment Management Company LCC in the United States and throughout the world. ©2017, PIMCO

This article was provided by Pimco and does not necessarily reflect the views of Citywire

Citywire TV
Play On the Road Challenge: Clay pigeon shooting with Thesis' Lansdowne

On the Road Challenge: Clay pigeon shooting with Thesis' Lansdowne

Eleanor Mahmoud goes clay shooting at the National Clay Shooting Centre with Sam Lansdowne from Thesis Asset Management

Play AA-rated Flood on gov't bonds: 'the maths doesn't add up'

AA-rated Flood on gov't bonds: 'the maths doesn't add up'

He also addresses why his Newton Multi-Asset Income fund has such a high cash weighting and why he sees renewables as such a good opportunity.

Play AAA-rated Ali: Identifying the peripheral European plays

AAA-rated Ali: Identifying the peripheral European plays

Citywire AAA-rated Tawhid Ali thinks that plenty of good stocks in the European periphery are being thrown out with the proverbial bath water.

Read More
Your Business: Cover Star Club

Profile: Brewin's Cardiff boss on the Welsh opportunity

Profile: Brewin's Cardiff boss on the Welsh opportunity

Prior to becoming head of Brewin Dolphin Cardiff, Welshman David Myrddin-Evans had only previously visited the city to watch the rugby.

Wealth Manager on Twitter