New Model Adviser - For professional financial planners

Register free for our breaking news email alerts with analysis and cutting edge commentary from our award winning team. Registration only takes a minute.

Robo roundtable: Restricted advice like buying an ill-fitting suit

Three leaders of robo advice firms discuss whether they offer advice, and offer their opinions on the advice vs guidance distinction, in the first of our series of videos.

The leaders of online investment firms raised concerns over the value of restricted advice in the first of our series of videos from a roundtable discussion.

The distinction between advice and guidance was also a hot topic for our panellists, as it has been at the heart of the Financial Conduct Authority’s Financial Advice Market Review.

Indeed, the very name 'robo-advice' proved very unsatisfactory to the business heads, given only some online firms offer regulated advice while many do not.

New Model Adviser® sat down with the heads of three robo firms, or 'digital wealth managers'.

  • Adam French, chief executive, Scalable Capital
  • Johann Bornman, director of product, ETFmatic
  • Giovanni Dapra, chief executive, Moneyfarm 

In this first episode, the three business leaders discussed their worries about the current definitions of advice, particularity between independent and restricted offerings.

As French said, restricted advice can be suitable but not the best possible deal for a client, 'like walking into a Mercedes Benz garage and asking them for advice on what car you should get' or 'walking out of the store wearing a suit, but it might not be a suit that looks good on you.' 

The panel discussed  how to secure the best outcome for clients, and how these definitions apply to their own business models.

Share this story

Leave a comment!

Please sign in or register to comment. It is free to register and only takes a minute or two.
More Content


Niche IFA delivers for local postie with football team sponsorship

Niche IFA delivers for local postie with football team sponsorship

Postmen usually knock on doors to deliver letters, not make requests. But when Newport-based Niche IFA’s Royal Mail regular came looking for support for his football club, he did not leave empty handed.


7 Comments Gov’t to move forward with creation of collective pensions

Gov’t to move forward with creation of collective pensions

The government will shortly consult on reforms to the private pension system to allow for collective defined contribution schemes to be introduced, it was announced today.