View the article online at http://citywire.co.uk/money/article/a987946
Investment Trust Watch: three plays on toppy markets
With many investment trusts on all-time highs we look at what bargain hunters at Hawskmoor Investment Management have been bagging.
With stock markets edging ever higher finding clear-cut bargains is not straightforward so I thought I would check in with what the investment trust experts at Hawksmoor Fund Managers have been buying.
This week the Association of Investment Companies cited figures from Winterflood Securities to show that a quarter of investment trusts, or 71 closed-end funds, had seen their share prices hit record highs this month.
No surprise then that only three of the 15 trusts in Numis Securities ‘cheap’ list (see first table) have a Z-score of -2 or below, which is the point at which analysts reckon a trust becomes inexpensive.
Just to recap, a Z-score is a measure used by analysts to show whether an investment trust is trading significantly beyond its one-year range. It’s a useful figure to use alongside the discounts and premiums investors ordinarily look at to see how a trust share price compares to its net asset value (NAV).
While a Z-score of -2 or below is regarded as ‘cheap’, a score of 2 or more is viewed as ‘expensive’. Fitting in with the theme of rallying markets, all the ‘expensive’ trusts in our second table have Z-scores well above 2, making them dear.
Gresham House Strategic
Before we hear from Hawksmoor, though, it’s worth highlighting Gresham House Strategic (GHS ), ranked fourth in the first table. Shares in the AIM-listed UK smaller companies fund stand at a whopping discount of over 27% below their NAV, the widest in its sector.
The fact its Z-score doesn't exceed -2 with this big discount underscores its low rating, which is a result of a low profile among investors and the fact that over a third of the portfolio is sitting in cash following a reorganisation of the portfolio by Gresham House Asset Management (GHAM), which took it over in 2015 (it was previously known as Spark Venture, the technology incubator).
It’s one to watch though as Gresham House employs a similar private equity approach to smaller companies as rival Strategic Equity Capital (SEC ), whose fund manager GVO Investment Management was bought by Lord Rothschild’s RIT Capital Partners (RCP ) after a successful run a few years ago.
It is no accident the two share the same philosophy as GHAM’s founder Tony Dalwood used to work at GVO. The portfolio is managed by his colleague Graham Bird.
|'Cheap' trusts||Share price premium (- discount) to net asset value %||12-month average premium (- discount) %||Z-score|
|Pacific Alliance China Land (PACL)||-25.0||-17.6||-2.5|
|Drum Income Plus REIT (DRIP)||6.4||11.5||-2.0|
|Qannas Investments (QIL)||-4.2||0.5||-2.0|
|Gresham House Strategic (GHS)||-27.5||-22.7||-1.7|
|JPMorgan Mid Cap (JMF)||-12.1||-6.5||-1.7|
|Investment Company (INV)||-7.2||-2.2||-1.6|
|Axiom European Financial Debt (AXI)||-4.9||2.5||-1.6|
|Qatar Investment Fund (QIF)||-18.1||-14.0||-1.5|
|Schroder European Real Estate (SERE)||-4.0||4.9||-1.4|
|NAXS Nordic Access Buyout (NAXS)||-11.8||-8.0||-1.3|
|Kennedy Wilson Europe Real Estate (KWE)||-21.9||-11.9||-1.3|
|Perpetual Income & Growth (PLI)||-8.5||-5.7||-1.3|
|CATCo Reinsurance Opportunities C (CATC)||-2.6||0.4||-1.3|
|Independent IT (IIT)||-7.6||-1.5||-1.3|
|Law Debenture (LWDB)||-12.0||-9.7||-1.2|
Source: Numis Securities 26/1/17
Exeter-based Hawksmoor, which is chaired by Citywire Money columnist David Kempton, is one of the few 'multi-asset' managers to use investment trusts as a way of gaining exposure to interesting assets at cheap valuations.
Both its Vanburgh and Distribution funds invest in other funds (ie, are 'fund of funds') and trading in and out of investment trusts as their discounts widen and narrow is a big factor in their good performance.
In a quarterly update this week it told investors in its funds that with both global equity and bond markets looking expensive it looked to 'expose investors to idiosyncratic risk - we're not relying on asset classes rising', said senior fund manager Ben Lockyer.
Henderson Alternative Strategies (HAST)
You don't get much more idiosyncratic than Henderson Alternative Strategies Trust (HAST ), a previously poorly peforming global fund of funds that Ian Barrass and James de Bunsen of Henderson Global Investors took over three years ago.
Their efforts at turning round the portfolio and getting the collection of 30 hard-to-access funds in to shape started to pay off last year with the shares rising 14.5% in the 12 months to September. While that was ahead of their 8% target it was below the 31% advance in FTSE World index.
Performance has continued to improve in recent months with an oversubscribed tender off to buy back 10% of its shares this week reducing the discount to 12%. This is much narrower than the 12-month average discount of 19.5% and gives it an expensive Z-score of 3.2, placing it near the top of our second table (see below).
Hawksmoor chief investment officer Richard Scott told me he had bought into HAST after meeting the managers a few months ago. He described it as 'an each-way bet as it is having much better performance with NAV but due to the long-term disappointing performance it stands at a big discount to NAV.'
With the trust facing a continuation vote later this year, Barrass and de Bunsen are under pressure to keep up the good work. If they succeed, the discount will probably narrow further, if they don't it may be wound up and shareholders given the full asset value minus costs. There could be more gains to come.
Standard Life Equity Income (SLET)
A more recent Hawskmoor purchase, Scott disclosed, was Thomas Moore's Standard Life Equity Income Trust (SLET ), which appeared in last week's 'cheap' list on an 8% discount and -1.5 Z-score. It's been a really tough 12 months for the fund whose big holdings in smaller and medium-sized stocks suffered from the Brexit vote, while the portfolio held none of the oil and mining stocks that have done well.
Also weighing down the stock last month was the final expiration of subscription shares given to shareholders in 2010. In anticipation of 3.9 million new shares hitting the market this month, the shares fell to a discount of 9% to NAV before Christmas, giving Hawksmoor its buying opportunity and which Winterflood Securities at the time described as an 'attractive entry point'.
The discount has since narrowed to 7% and the Z-score improved to -1.1 meaning the bargain is not as good as it was but arguably it's still a low level to get the skills of a previously highly rated fund manager. Until the EU referendum Moore had been consistently rated for five years by Citywire for the performance of his Standard Life Investments UK Equity fund and in the 18 months before the Brexit vote held our top AAA rating. He is currently unrated but may bounce back if conditions return to his favour.
Ranger Direct a 'leader'
Scott said Hawksmoor had topped up a small holding after being reassured by Ranger that it would recover its money and the quarterly dividends supporting its 8.9% yield would not be affected. 'Ben [Conway] has done a lot of work on it. We've got a toe in the water and do think it is the clear leader in its sector.'
Ranger is the best performing of the new breed of direct lending or peer-to-peer funds with a 20% total shareholder return over one year. In the past week the discount has narrowed from 17% to 12.5%, a bit wider than the 12-month average of 10%, giving it a Z-score of -0.8, according to Numis.
|'Expensive' trusts||Share price premium (- discount) to net asset value %||12-month average premium (- discount) %||Z-score|
|Better Capital 2012 (BC12)||-44.9||-65.7||4.4|
|Fidelity Asian Values (FAS)||-4.1||-11.1||3.2|
|Henderson Alternative Strategies (HAST)||-11.9||-19.5||3.2|
|HBM Healthcare Investments (HBMN)||-21.9||-29.2||3.0|
|Prospect Japan (PJF)||-11.3||-26.5||3.0|
|Eurocastle Investment (ECT)||3.5||-13.7||3.0|
|Symphony International Holding (SIHL)||-30.2||-42.4||2.8|
|Alliance Trust (ATST)||-4.9||-9.9||2.5|
|Aberdeen Private Equity (APEF)||-19.4||-30.4||2.5|
|Apax Global Alpha (APAX)||-7.7||-16.6||2.5|
|BlackRock Frontiers (BRFI)||4.8||-0.7||2.5|
|Ratos AB B (RATOB)||67.3||33.2||2.5|
|Africa Opportunity C (AOFC)||-14.9||-22.0||2.4|
|Altamir Amboise (LTA)||-30.8||-40.7||2.3|
|Foresight Solar (FSFL)||8.5||0.0||2.3|
Source: Numis Securities 26/1/17
No shock to see Alliance Trust (ATST), which I hold in my pension, in our second table. Its discount has halved to 5% in response to determined share buy backs from the board and today's news that activist Elliott Associates, its largest investor, has agreed to sell its 19.5% stake bodes well for next month's vote on the proposed new 'multi-manager' strategy and, if that is successful, perhaps its long-term future.
News sponsored by:
Making the most out of Europe's potential means seeing things differently. Learn more about how BlackRock's focused approach to investing in Europe helps investors unlock the continent's vast potential.
In this guide to investment trusts, produced in association with Aberdeen Asset Management, we spoke to many of the leading experts in the field to find out more.
More about this:
Look up the funds
Look up the shares
- Pacific Alliance China Land Ltd
- NAXS Nordic Access Buyout Fund AB (publ)
- HBM Healthcare Investments AG
- Eurocastle Investment Ltd
- Ratos AB
- Africa Opportunity Fund Ltd
- Altamir SCA
Look up the investment trusts
- Drum Income Plus REIT (Ordinary Share)
- Qannas Investments (Ordinary Share)
- Gresham House Strategic (Ordinary Share)
- JPMorgan Mid Cap (Ordinary Share)
- Investment Company (Ordinary Share)
- Qatar Investment Fund (Ordinary Share)
- Schroder European Real Estate (Ordinary Share)
- Kennedy Wilson Europe Real Est (Ordinary Share)
- Perpetual Income (Ordinary Share)
- CATCo Reinsurance Opps 'C' (Ordinary Share)
- Independent (Ordinary Share)
- Law Debenture Corporation (Ordinary Share)
- Better Capital PCC 2012 (Ordinary Share)
- Fidelity Asian Values (Ordinary Share)
- Henderson Alt. Strategies (Ordinary Share)
- Prospect Japan (Ordinary Share)
- Symphony International Holding (Ordinary Share)
- Alliance Trust (Ordinary Share)
- Aberdeen Private Equity (Ordinary Share)
- Apax Global Alpha (Ordinary Share)
- BlackRock Frontiers (Ordinary Share)
- Foresight Solar (Ordinary Share)
- Standard Life Equity Income (Ordinary Share)
- Ranger Direct Lending Fund (Ordinary Share)
- Strategic Equity Capital (Ordinary Share)
- RIT Capital Partners (Ordinary Share)
More from us
- Investment Trust Watch: Hawksmoor's Brexit bargains
- Investment Trust Watch: catastrophe, property or bust!
- David Kempton: the art of the deal is not ideal
- Elliott ends war with Alliance Trust
Tools from Citywire Money
From the Forums
Weekly email from The Lolly
Get simple, easy ways to make more from your money. Just enter your email address below
An error occured while subscribing your email. Please try again later.
Thank you for registering for your weekly newsletter from The Lolly.
Keep an eye out for us in your inbox, and please add email@example.com to your safe senders list so we don't get junked.